SHREDDEDAF
Supplement audits/Body composition
Category 06 / Body composition

Body composition,
audited.

Meal replacements assessed as convenient foods—not fat-loss shortcuts. Protein, fibre, micronutrient coverage, certification and label realism drive the score.

Category boundary. No powder causes fat loss independently of energy balance and adherence. These products are not a sole-source diet and are not a substitute for individual medical or nutrition care.
Provisional audit order

3 products. Six separate scores.

This is a transparent first field, not a universal “best” list. Formula, certification, claim risk and value remain separate.

#ProductTotalTesting signalValue
1Raw Organic MealPlant meal replacement84NSF Contents Certified7 / 10
2Black Edition PowderHigh-protein complete meal82Company quality system9 / 10
3Protein Meal Replacement BlendLow-calorie meal replacement72No exact public register located10 / 10
All auditedMeal replacementHigh proteinPlant based
Garden of Life Raw Organic Meal lightly sweet powder tub#01 provisional
Plant meal replacement

Raw Organic Meal

A certified organic, vegan meal powder with an unusually broad certification stack. The label is credible; “manage weight” remains a contextual claim, not an independent product effect.

FormatMeal powder
Audit score84
Huel Black Edition high-protein meal powder bags#02 provisional
High-protein complete meal

Black Edition Powder

A high-protein vegan complete meal with 40 g protein and fibre in a structured serving. Strong nutrition disclosure; weaker independent product-level certification than the category leader.

Protein / 90 g serving40 g
Audit score82
Myprotein Protein Meal Replacement Blend Salted Caramel pouch#03 provisional
Low-calorie meal replacement

Protein Meal Replacement Blend

A 200-calorie, high-protein meal-replacement formula with vitamins and minerals. It is commercially accessible, but formula complexity and a thin public testing trail cap the score.

Energy / serving200 kcal
Audit score72

Ingredient ≠ product

Strong evidence for an ingredient does not prove a particular tub contains the claimed dose or deserves a premium.

Testing has borders

A certificate applies only to the exact product, region and batches the directory lists.

Commercial wall

No active retailer or affiliate link appears here. Future monetised links will be labelled and cannot alter a score.